Відео

this is a fucking masterclass... greetings from brazil

This is great comedy.

Phenomenal breakdown!

Sorry you're American so I'm not listening to anything you say about race or politics. Yank detected = opinion rejected. It's what the cringe race nerds from the US do to white people so I just do it back

I can't hear this manlet over my mad piano skills

2 instruments that arrived in India to convert the "Pagans" "Heretics " from UK.Portugal were Violins and Harmonium which I personally vastly dislike These 2 Instruments part of the colonizers Racism enforced on Music in "?conquered" Asia/ Africa CHINA... z To quote The great musician Miles Davies.. we whatever colour or ethnicity worship "Dead White Music" with tasty hi falutin labels such as Baroque Classical etc

Isn't music colour blind with lavels thrust upon. It...? I am not sure That all "White ( western) colonizing" music is "classical" and the music of 'conquered by Whites = "Primitive or Ethno music?" Music has no alphabet .. Labels added to it.. now Cross over Racism . Wokeistic????

07:53 I just found this video yesterday. This is a nitpicky ghost-discussion. There is no politisation of musical taste required. If i like and enjoy a musical composition or interpretation, the gender or race of the writer/performer doesnt matter. I can listen to Beethoven or Clara Schumann as well as to Scott Joplin, Aretha Franklin or Anne-Sophie Mutter. An idelogical recontextualiztion of listening preferences will not solve any percieved disadvantage. What should that even look like - I have to listen to 10 gender/race-diverse pianists before I am ideologically allowed to listen to Glenn Gould, if ever? Such a method will lead to exclusion of music or performers, based on purely political and arbitrary pseudo-criteria. This is very dangerous. This sounds very much like Chinese culture revolution or the Nazi-term "Enartete Kunst" - ideologically inappropriate works are censored or forbidden and their authors/performers will be subjected to harassment, persecution, imprisonment or worse. Do you know how brainwashed you sound?

I was so surprised to see this have tens of thousands of views less than I thought it would, criminal

I'm so bored with this discussion!

This was a joke, right?

I enjoy listening to woke speak. It's like like listening to a cult member.

Why does Google insist on pushing anti-Classical (and "anti-White") narrative in its algorithm music now? So tiring!

Did you get your wish granted with infinite? Thank you for making this little piece of nostalgia video, it was very enjoyable.

i'm not among the edgelord right-wingers spouting racist bullshit in the comments but your arguments are sort of one-dimensional. no ones denying that classical musics rooted in colonialist/imperialist history, but neglecting the fact that classical music as a wholes dying for reasons that have nothing 2 do with race or that imperialist history is a fools errand. also your advice just makes supporting marginalized artists a chore to do rather than something thats rewarding n fun. as a autistic trans woman i don't want 2 fucking track how much music i'm listening 2 is by poc, how many composers i listen 2 that are in the realm ov dead white man composers.

I’m finding this much after it’s upload date but I appreciate the perspectives you are bringing to this! As a gigging percussionist/engineer/composer, I find myself at a weird intersection of this all the time as a Middle Eastern/South Asian person existing in music spaces. While I can’t always speak on the experiences of other POC, i appreciate the parallels we all experience navigating this career path

Anyone who thinks that classical music is racist has a head that is made almost completely out of meat. By the way, I'm sure that Jay-Z And other pop stars and rap artists are gonna give back all the money earned using classical string riffs all throughout this music, among other classical tropes. I really miss Americans worrying about shit that makes sense to worry about & that actually matters.

Apple did NOT control Bungie. They were and are a totally separate company - they just primarily released their games for the Mac (Pathways Into Darkness, and two of the three Marathon titles - Marathon II and Myth were released on Windows as well). Like many companies that had really good Mac implementations (or were Mac-only) they were featured on-stage at Macworld and WWDC.

Don't forget Bungie's earlier work: Marathon - which had quite a storyline also.

Everything will sound stupid or harmless until you learn who the enemy is. i suggest you learn what the occult, witchcraft and voodoo really is (not what you see in movies), only then will you have a clearer understanding of what is truly being said.

So if i get influenced by japanese pop music i am culture appropriating wtf how would music evolved if not influenced 😂

What is kinda funny to me is when Americans debate whether classical music is racist or not despite the lack of properly understanding it like Europeans do. I know Americans have adopted the classical as a term to label their movie and theater scores. Many classical music pieces have inspired movie score titles. And I love lots of those. But I would never consider those scores as part of what is called classical music. And on top of that I can easily replace any movie score title with something from Mahler, Wagner, Shostakovich, Brahms etc. without blinking once. Most scores by Danny Elfman can be replaced with anything written by Mahler. John Williams music? Wagner. Wagner's Ring cycle still blows your typical score out of the waters. Gatekeeping is still a meaningful tool to keep the completely uninitiated out of it and prevent them from talking nonsense inside the circles. Otherwise appropriation is non existing in regards to classical musichence everyone can get an instrument and start playing. That's what happened in the past. People listened, took a sheet and started to play the piece at home. Today this is similar with music by Philip Glass. This man, a great modern composer and conductor who still lives, has his music copied and replayed by others many times already with other musicians pumping out their recordings while Mr. Glass still produces his next tunes.

Every time I think of syncopation Tehillim gets stuck in my head. "IT IS A PRINC- ITISAPRINCIPLE PRINCIIIPLE OF MUUUSIC TO REPEAT REPEAT REPEAT REPEAT "

Would love to see your take on some of Ace Combat's music.

How about black privlege in blues and soul music?

Be it is as it may, modern worship msuic is really crappy. I prefer 1960's southern gospel - regardless whether sung by black or white people. And not just as a personal preference, this music is just stronger

This was an incredibly well done video essay, especially considering (to echo other comments) the criminally low number of views. The close connection of OTGW to Schubert's song cycle in particular was a really fascinating observation! I'll definitely be checking out other things you made :)

Alpha vs Beta, Either Berdahl with his limited knowledge is quoting scientists from NCBI and scienceDirect who do not make sense , or O'Dell with your degree in music and your personal opinions do not make sense! So far you are the less convincing!

Alpha vs Beta.... "These results suggest that syncopation influences emotional valence (positively), and that while syncopated rhythms are objectively more complex than unsyncopated rhythms," NCBI PMC3259101/

Adam you stated that you have the credentials to rebuke Berdahl presentation, but you have failed in your attempt because you seems not to have any coherent understanding of his presentation or even of the topic that you addressed. For example, on the Alpha versus Beta you claimed that "really the beta that he's sort of going for is actually triggered more by syncopated music..."

👎

This dude looks like a more fit call me carson

NOICE

Rewatching these videos again. Still so great.

This video deserves far more views than it has. Well done. I don’t even know music theory but I enjoyed every minute.

Adam, you are wrong.

It's not that deep. Its suppose to be a sauber mellancolic and serious note to denote the underlying gravity of the main plot. Then the rock music starts which is the start of the military music you could imagine soldiers listen to to prepare for battle. This is also put in the perspective of a hero journey and 117 is the hero kind of. This typ of first serious then action is used by literally every composer out there. The idea that it's iconic is due to the fact that it's good, but mainly to be honest it's because of the franchise success overall.

A church musician laughing at serious things...I'm not inclined to listen to you. You seem indifferent with spiritual things.

its been a year or more and this still hasnt blown up. subbed, great analysis

It's not even October yet but I'm so so so glad I discovered your channel! Definitely gonna be one of my favorites

The tune of Come Wayward souls is the same melody as the Lacrymosa from Verdi's requiem! I've always thought the melody sounded a lot like Mahler, so it's fun to see you compare it to a german Lieder

The minor key section remendes me you when you get a Ocarina song wrong from oot

You're guilty that's why you are so defensive. You study musicology? I'm disappointed. People claim to be wise, they became fools.

You are unreasonable brother, I don't see your point you are just laughing! Please stand aside ,let the light shine

When you realise it’s a genre of music and stop making a problem out of nothing :🫥

Are you Jewish?

This is a really good video.

seriously dude! just stop

The last beat is so rebellious brother.

Why do you think we should try you and your ideas? Be humble and make research about music before you speak